Personally, I think this would be an excellent hire for Alabama. Kiffin did well enough as an OC and he's an excellent recruiter. Now, could he recruit without bending and breaking the rules? That would be the interesting part. I'm all for it just to see if he can land Alabama under the NCAA's jail in a few years.
I was NOT impressed with his play calling at all.
I will give him credit for the development of the QB and some good game plans (the uga game plan was totally different than what we had been doing and was effected as heck) but in game play calling was just plain weird at times, and was demonstrated repeatedly at SCw.