Dooley never....
Lost to an FCS team at home (see Georgia Southern last year)
Lost more than 7 games
Had nearly as much talent as UF had and still has
Lost to a team at the level of Missouri by that margin
On the other hand, Muschamp did
Go 11-1 one year. Dools never sniffed that.
Lose to Kentucky
So here is what I think....looking at the whole of each's careers at UT and UF, respectively, Dooley overall was worse, but Muschamp has finished worse, by far.
At least in his last season Dooley was ALMOST (very frustratingly) beating good teams. The cluster fizzle down in Gainesville is much worse than 2011.
Given expectations and where he found the program, Muschamp may well be the biggest bust of all time.