VTTW Board Index

Sports => VTTW Message Board => Topic started by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 03:58:28 EDT



Title: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 03:58:28 EDT
QB Nate Peterman from Fruit Cove FL has committed. He is 3 stars and had offers from Cincinnati, UConn, Vandy, and Wake Forest.

I need a "no emotion" emoticon.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: VinnieVOL on July 20, 2011, 04:05:28 EDT
Do want DT's.  Plzkthxbai.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 04:09:02 EDT
Do want DT's.  Plzkthxbai.

DT's and LB's. Literally the rest of our class could be DTs and LBs plus one OL (Humpheries from NC) and I'd call it a day.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: murfvol on July 20, 2011, 04:24:33 EDT
Is he a potential db? I assume Brewer and Jackson are gone after this year so that area may not be super loaded for the future. That having been said I'd like some front 7 guys.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 04:26:57 EDT
Is he a potential db? I assume Brewer and Jackson are gone after this year so that area may not be super loaded for the future. That having been said I'd like some front 7 guys.

No, he's a pro style QB.

I don't think DB is a priority in this class. They signed a ton of DBs in last class and played a lot of young guys there last year. Gordon was a frosh, Waggner and Teague sophs, Byron Moore comes in from JUCO with 3 to play 3, plus they signed several HS guys.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: 101stDad on July 20, 2011, 04:36:13 EDT
No, he's a pro style QB.

I don't think DB is a priority in this class. They signed a ton of DBs in last class and played a lot of young guys there last year. Gordon was a frosh, Waggner and Teague sophs, Byron Moore comes in from JUCO with 3 to play 3, plus they signed several HS guys.

Plus they have offers out to a couple of DBs already, Knoxville Central's Cody Blanc being one of them. 

You are correct - we need big uglies and LBs. 


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: murfvol on July 20, 2011, 05:12:31 EDT
O.k., I'm puzzled, especially since Byron Moore has 3 years left. It's possible Nash Nances leaves and obviously Simms will, but my thought is you can offer near the end to get a third QB. Oh well, I'll see how everything shakes out in February.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 05:21:04 EDT
O.k., I'm puzzled, especially since Byron Moore has 3 years left. It's possible Nash Nances leaves and obviously Simms will, but my thought is you can offer near the end to get a third QB. Oh well, I'll see how everything shakes out in February.

Coaches can't and don't recruit that way though... they don't say we're taking 3 DBs now and a QB later. They identify who they want at all positions and offer who they want and take the commits as they come, based on how many spots they have available. Dooley has been obvious about taking one QB in this class.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: 101stDad on July 20, 2011, 05:31:00 EDT
Coaches can't and don't recruit that way though... they don't say we're taking 3 DBs now and a QB later. They identify who they want at all positions and offer who they want and take the commits as they come, based on how many spots they have available. Dooley has been obvious about taking one QB in this class.

Yep, you have to go out and get a quality QB pretty much every year.  With the potential for injuries, transfers, just plain flame outs, and academic busts, a program always has to have 4 or 5 QBs in the program. 

Besides, most prospects don't shy away from competition.  They believe in their minds that they are the best, hands down, and are going to beat out whoever might be in a particular program already.  If a prospect is afraid to compete then that tells one a lot about their makeup and perhaps it's best that he does go elsewhere. 


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 05:32:06 EDT
Coaches can't and don't recruit that way though... they don't say we're taking 3 DBs now and a QB later. They identify who they want at all positions and offer who they want and take the commits as they come, based on how many spots they have available. Dooley has been obvious about taking one QB in this class.

Now, that being said... I wish we were competing with better offer lists when we offer a QB. Most people in the recruiting services think this guy is underrated though. They must because usually that sort of offer list gets you two stars. Of course I trust the coaches at big schools more than the recruiting services too.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 05:34:49 EDT
Yep, you have to go out and get a quality QB pretty much every year.  With the potential for injuries, transfers, just plain flame outs, and academic busts, a program always has to have 4 or 5 QBs in the program. 

Besides, most prospects don't shy away from competition.  They believe in their minds that they are the best, hands down, and are going to beat out whoever might be in a particular program already.  If a prospect is afraid to compete then that tells one a lot about their makeup and perhaps it's best that he does go elsewhere. 

This is true. Bray was also an underrated prospect. If he blows up this year as we hope, he's gone after 2012 on his way to the draft... you need guys who have been on campus and who are ready to step in. It's no coincidence that Tee won a NC as a first year starter after sitting behind Peyton for 2 years. We tried to foster the same thing with Joey Mathews and it didn't pan out, mostly because he was overrated.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: BanditVol on July 20, 2011, 05:46:31 EDT
This is true. Bray was also an underrated prospect. If he blows up this year as we hope, he's gone after 2012 on his way to the draft...

That would be great, but I don't see it happening.  I don't mean to imply you thought it was likely, because I am pretty sure you did not, I just wanted to comment on Bray's prospects.

To which, given how incredibly soft the defenses were at the end of last year, I am still in wait and see mode.  In some of our games a HS D might have been more of a challenge.

Obviously I want him to do well, but my expectations are dialed down a notch.  Let's see if he can get it done against the gators in gtown and then I might be an optimist.

But at this point I think it highly unlikely he will ever be considered a prospect to go pro early.  I would LOVE for him to prove me wrong though.   :biggrin:


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: ReVOLver on July 20, 2011, 05:58:01 EDT
That would be great, but I don't see it happening.  I don't mean to imply you thought it was likely, because I am pretty sure you did not, I just wanted to comment on Bray's prospects.

To which, given how incredibly soft the defenses were at the end of last year, I am still in wait and see mode.  In some of our games a HS D might have been more of a challenge.

Obviously I want him to do well, but my expectations are dialed down a notch.  Let's see if he can get it done against the gators in gtown and then I might be an optimist.

But at this point I think it highly unlikely he will ever be considered a prospect to go pro early.  I would LOVE for him to prove me wrong though.   :biggrin:

Yeah... definitely don't think it's likely... just possible. Something that the coaches need to be prepared for.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: Black Diamond Vol on July 20, 2011, 09:49:47 EDT
Now, that being said... I wish we were competing with better offer lists when we offer a QB. Most people in the recruiting services think this guy is underrated though. They must because usually that sort of offer list gets you two stars. Of course I trust the coaches at big schools more than the recruiting services too.

"Trust the coach" is an overused cliche when it comes to recruiting, but early returns on the Dooley regime suggest it may carry more weight with him.  A lot of those supposed "space fillers" that committed in the last two weeks after Kiffin left turned out to make some pretty significant contributions last year. 

When it came to getting max output from unheralded recruits, Tommy Tuberville was the best I've ever seen.  If Dooley can approach that level (and his first class is certainly a positive indicator), then we're going to be just fine.


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: 101stDad on July 20, 2011, 10:01:57 EDT
"Trust the coach" is an overused cliche when it comes to recruiting, but early returns on the Dooley regime suggest it may carry more weight with him. 

I tend to agree with you on this one.  I know for a fact that Dooley and his coaches are working harder than the last Fulmer staff (Kiffin's staff wasn't here long enough for me to make a statement either way on) did in it's last 4 or 5 years when it comes to working high school coaches and potential recruits.  They aren't just relying on star ratings from the recruiting services.  They are seeing more kids in person at their prospect camps and during allowable contact periods during high school spring practices than the previous staff did and doing a genuine job of trying to build relationships with the high school coaches.  Much of the previous staff seemed to only be interested in giving the high school coaches lip service instead of trying to build a real relationship with them.  In the end, that is what doomed them, in my opinion. 


Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: Volznut on July 20, 2011, 10:13:15 EDT
Peterman looks great in the film I saw. Coaches must have really liked him at camp



Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: Volznut on July 20, 2011, 10:15:03 EDT
That would be great, but I don't see it happening.  I don't mean to imply you thought it was likely, because I am pretty sure you did not, I just wanted to comment on Bray's prospects.

To which, given how incredibly soft the defenses were at the end of last year, I am still in wait and see mode.  In some of our games a HS D might have been more of a challenge.

Obviously I want him to do well, but my expectations are dialed down a notch.  Let's see if he can get it done against the gators in gtown and then I might be an optimist.

But at this point I think it highly unlikely he will ever be considered a prospect to go pro early.  I would LOVE for him to prove me wrong though.   :biggrin:

Bray will be a top 10 pick if he continues to progress, AFTER THE 2012 season. There's already a mock draft in 2013 that has him as the #1 pick. He has the tools to do it.



Title: Re: Another commit
Post by: BanditVol on July 21, 2011, 05:28:57 EDT
Bray will be a top 10 pick if he continues to progress, AFTER THE 2012 season. There's already a mock draft in 2013 that has him as the #1 pick. He has the tools to do it.



A 2013 draft projection?  LOL.  I think that proves my point more than anything.  Good grief, do you also believe tech analysis can actually predict future stock prices? 

Seriously though, I will believe Bray when he faces a level of defense somewhat higher than "vapor".