parameters you use to call him the greatest qb in history.
That's easy...100% orange-colored bias.
![](https://volstothewall.com/board/Smileys/default/biggrin.gif)
When I typed that I was deliberating overhyping him.
But on a serious note, he is definitely in the discussion of "all time greatest NFL quarterback" if for no other reason than he was well on his way to breaking every NFL record in site prior to the injury, and has had his share of wins and the one Super Bowl.
I think even his critics would agree that if there is a consensus on the "top 10 quarterbacks" he is in it. And non-critics or the unbiased would agree he is in the discussion for "greatest of all".
ANd what I also think most people agree on is that it kind of depends on how you weight the categories...stats vs. wins vs. championships, etc, and let's factor in the different styles of different eras also. At the end of the day, I don't think you really can say any one QB is "the greatest", but you can certainly talk about a top group, and Peyton is definitely in that.